All articles · Vendor management
When ending a supplier relationship goes wrong
By Celia SGAR · 5 min read
Supplier exits go wrong because nobody planned them. You decide to leave, and only then find out which teams depend on the supplier, what their people know that you never wrote down, and what the contract says about leaving. A good exit ends with the service running, the knowledge in your hands and a relationship you could reopen.
Why do supplier exits go wrong?
Most exits I see start as a reaction. A renewal date lands, a new leader wants to consolidate, or a supplier fails once too often. The decision comes fast, and nobody prepared for it.
When you do decide, the contract often gives you little to work with. One manager I spoke to opened a three-year-old contract to decide whether to keep a tool and found a single SLA (what else she found).
Low-spend suppliers spread the furthest. A Head of IT Operations told me about a workflow automation tool that started as a €28K pilot, small enough that procurement barely noticed. Eighteen months later it was running customer onboarding, invoice approvals, IT tickets and employee offboarding across 12 departments. It was still classified as Tier 3, with an annual review and nobody managing it. Then the vendor had a four-hour outage, and someone finally asked who managed the relationship. Nobody did. You find out how far a supplier like that reaches when it stops, or when you try to take it out.
Some suppliers know you cannot leave, as one of my clients found with their ERP vendor (what that cost them). Being stuck is rarely about the contract alone. It sits in the integrations, the data and a nervous team. Month after month, you pay more and get less, and the vendor knows you are not going anywhere.
What walks out the door when a supplier leaves?
Knowledge. The most useful information about a supplier sits with the people who work with them every day. They know who picks up the phone, who goes quiet in August and what got promised and never showed up. Nobody writes it down.
A project manager once caught me in the corridor and told me that a vendor had swapped its senior engineers for juniors six months earlier, while we were still paying senior rates. She had known for months and assumed somebody already knew. I had spent three weeks reading contracts, SLAs and old slide decks, and I knew every payment term, but I could not have told you which vendors were not performing. That fifteen-minute conversation told me more.
I have been the person handing over. Early in my career I was sent to Kerala to train the team that would replace me. I spent three months passing on my processes, my systems and my role, with the person who held the knowledge in the room and committed to handing it over. Most supplier exits get a fraction of that time, and the supplier's people holding the knowledge already know they are on the way out.
Commitments leave too. Whatever you agreed in meetings leaves with the people who were in them, as one of my clients found when she inherited a vendor with no handover (her story).
You also need the outgoing supplier's goodwill at the end, and suppliers decide which clients get their best people (what suppliers decide about you). Sometimes the supplier is the one who leaves: one of our best-scoring suppliers once declined to bid on a renewal because we only called when something was wrong.
Is the supplier the problem?
Replacing a bad vendor is the easy part. Fixing the process that made them fail is harder. Unclear expectations, one governance meeting at kick-off, feedback held back until things blew up, a messy internal handover. If you leave those in place, the next supplier will fail too. When I work with my clients, an exit follows evidence: performance data both sides have seen, and a record of what you did about it, so the decision does not come as a surprise to the supplier.
How do you know an exit will hurt?
You know you have this when:
- •Nobody can say which teams and processes depend on the supplier.
- •The supplier's people know things about your service that nobody on your side has written down.
- •Nobody has read the contract since signature, so nobody knows what it says about leaving.
- •The case for leaving rests on frustration, with no scorecard behind it.
- •The supplier knows you cannot leave.
What does a good exit look like?
A good exit is a decision you make with your eyes open. One named owner can tell you in a single call which services, data and people the supplier touches. What the supplier knows about your service is already written down on your side before anyone gives notice. The new supplier starts with a clear picture of what it is taking on. And the relationship ends on terms that would let either side pick up the phone again.
When I work with my clients, the exit is part of managing the supplier from the start. So the day you decide to leave, you already know what you hold, who depends on the supplier and what you need from them on the way out.
Thinking about leaving a supplier, or worried you couldn't?
Book a diagnostic call. I will ask about your vendor base and how you review your suppliers, and tell you whether a day would fix it.
Book a diagnostic call →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call