All articles · SRM

Where your negotiated savings go after signature

By Celia SGAR · 4 min read

The savings you negotiated leak away during delivery. You sign the contract, procurement moves on to the next RFP, and nobody owns whether the supplier delivers what you paid for. Service credits go unclaimed, scope drifts and invoices stop matching the contract. Nobody reopens the business case, so the savings stay on a slide and never reach your budget.

Where do negotiated savings go after signature?

A procurement director called me three months into a $5M vendor contract. Her team had negotiated 99.9% uptime. The vendor had delivered 99.5% for two months, and she wanted to know what to do.

I asked whether she had claimed the service credit. She didn't know there was one. It sat on page 47, section 8.3: SLA breaches triggered 5% monthly credits. She had overpaid the vendor $25,000 a month for six months. That is $150,000 her team won at the negotiating table and then handed back.

The money sat in the contract the whole time. Her team had no one comparing the contract with what the vendor delivered each month.

This is contract value leakage, and WorldCC research puts a number on it: companies lose around 9% of contract value, on average, after signing. On a $10M contract, that is $900,000 gone after the deal looked finished.

You know you have this when...

Why does nobody check the business case after the contract?

Procurement spends weeks on the contract: SLAs, pricing, deliverables, escalation clauses. Then everyone moves on. Procurement goes to the next RFP, IT to the next implementation, operations to the next crisis. The supplier is left wondering who to call and whether anyone is paying attention.

The relationship lands on someone's desk by default, often an IT or operations lead who never saw the negotiation and never got a handover. Procurement owns the contract. Operations lives with the consequences. Nobody owns the performance in between.

Most savings trackers stop at signature too. The team reports the discount, leadership files the business case, and nobody asks anyone to prove the number arrived. Squeezing suppliers for discounts is easier than tracking whether they deserve one, and most leadership teams reward the discount.

What does the leak cost you?

The first cost is the money you already won: unclaimed credits, invoices above scope, services you pay for and never receive. The $150,000 above is one contract and one clause.

The second cost arrives at renewal. Without performance data, the supplier controls the conversation, and a request for a price increase goes through because you have nothing to answer it with (contracts that renew by default).

Performance data works even when you can't walk away. One client's ERP vendor announced a 2% licence increase, knowing a switch would take four years and cost millions. We showed the vendor where adoption was low. The vendor dropped the increase and €900,000 stayed in the budget that year.

The third cost is credibility. Most CPOs I've worked with told me the same thing: their team does the work, and the business still doesn't feel the impact. Procurement reports savings, the business doesn't feel them, and the team ends up defending its value with numbers nobody outside procurement recognises.

What good looks like

The value you negotiated reaches the budget, and someone can prove it. Each critical supplier has a named owner who can tell you, in one call, whether the supplier delivered what the contract and the business case promised. Your team claims service credits in the month they fall due. You report savings at renewal against what you signed, and you walk into that renewal with the performance data in your hand.

When I work with my clients, the first question I ask is who owns each critical supplier after signature. The answer is often nobody, or several teams at once. The procurement director above recovered her $150,000 within 30 days of someone owning the tracking. Her contract already held the money. Her team needed someone to own the supplier and check the delivery every month.

I spent 17+ years in vendor management at PepsiCo, Nestlé, Danone and Zurich Insurance, on the client side and the supplier side, and I saw the same gap in each of them: plenty of attention on the negotiation, and little on the months that follow it.

If your savings stop at signature

This is the work I do with clients in the Vendor Management Reset: one day to segment your vendors, build a working scorecard and name an owner. Remote or on site, EUR 5,000.

See the Vendor Management Reset →

Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call