All articles · Vendor management
Your supplier contracts renew by default and nobody decides
By Celia SGAR · 5 min read
A supplier contract renews by default when the renewal date arrives and nobody in your company can say how that supplier has performed. Procurement signed it, IT or operations use it, and each side assumes the other is watching. The contract rolls over on the old terms, or the supplier sets the new price, because you have no evidence to answer with.
What does a default renewal look like?
A Group Product Manager at a large company told me about a niche marketing platform her team had used for three years. It auto-renewed. She was consolidating apps across her team and wanted a clean answer: keep it or kill it.
So she opened the contract. It held one SLA, for availability. It said nothing about support response times, data handling or how the integrations should perform. In those three years her business had grown around the tool, with more users, more processes and more teams depending on it every day. Several internal stakeholders touched it, and each assumed somebody else reviewed it. Nobody did.
The supplier delivered what the contract asked for. Her company had signed a contract that asked for almost nothing and then let it renew without looking.
I saw the same at Nestlé and Danone. Big companies, proper processes, and a business-as-usual routine where the processes ran and nobody checked the output. Nobody notices until something breaks, and then it turns urgent and non-compliant overnight.
How do you know your contracts renew by default?
You know you have this problem when you recognise several of these:
- •A supplier calls about a renewal and you have to ask which contract they mean.
- •The supplier keeps better records of your contract than you do.
- •Nobody can name the person who owns the supplier's performance between signature and renewal.
- •The notice period passes before anyone has discussed whether to renew.
- •The renewal meeting is next month and people are asking for numbers for the first time.
- •The best answer anyone gives to "how have they performed?" is "they're fine".
I lived the first two in my first vendor management role. I inherited a SharePoint folder with 38 contracts in it, and some of them weren't even the latest version. I had to email a supplier to ask for the signed copy. On day three a vendor called about a renewal. I didn't know which contract he meant. He said "the one we signed last year". There were five from last year. I told him I'd call back, and I called back six days later.
What does "they're fine" cost you?
Years ago I sat in a renewal discussion for a $4M supplier contract. The CFO asked how the supplier had performed. The procurement lead said they were fine, no major issues. The CFO asked for data. We had none. We were about to renew a $4M contract on "they're fine".
When we dug into it, on-time delivery sat at 73% against the 95% the supplier claimed. We found 8 quality issues in six months where they had reported 2. Average support response took 12 days against a 24-hour SLA. "Fine" was costing us hundreds of thousands.
After that wake-up call I built scorecards for every Tier 1 supplier. Three of our "fine" suppliers turned out to be underperforming. One went on a performance improvement plan. The other two stepped up as soon as they realised we were measuring.
A default renewal also hands the price conversation to the supplier. A supplier should earn more by delivering more, and a date in the calendar gives them no reason to. When the account manager of a Tier 1 vendor came to a renewal asking for a 15% increase, I had a year of quarterly scores showing project delays, reopened tickets and zero proactivity. The increase came off the table.
The same holds when you can't leave, as one of my clients found when their ERP vendor asked for more (where your negotiated savings go).
Why does nobody decide?
Procurement signs the contract and moves on to the next one. The teams who use the supplier assume procurement is watching it, and procurement assumes they are. Nobody owns the supplier's performance between signature and renewal (who owns this supplier?).
So in the month before renewal everyone needs numbers at once. Procurement pushes for a 5% discount and calls it a win, while operations has spent three months dealing with missed deadlines, wrong resources and SLA breaches on their own. By the time you sit at the table, you have accepted the supplier's version of the story, because you never wrote your own.
A divided team makes it worse. When IT, finance and procurement bring different agendas to the review, the supplier's account manager notices within minutes (I have watched it happen).
What does a deliberate renewal look like?
Someone in your company owns each important supplier and can tell you in one call how that supplier has performed against what your business needs today, which may differ from what it needed at signature. The renewal date and the notice period sit in that person's diary long before anyone gets nervous. IT, finance and procurement walk into the renewal with one view.
When a supplier asks for more money, you answer with a year of scores. When a supplier has earned more of your business, you can show that too, and you decide to renew, extend, renegotiate or exit with evidence on the table.
When I work with my clients, the first gap we find is ownership. Once someone owns the supplier, procurement has clean data before every renewal and the people who use the service get heard in the reviews.
Do your contracts renew while nobody is looking?
If this is your team, this is the work I do with clients in the Vendor Management Reset: one day to segment your vendors, build a working scorecard and name an owner. Remote or on site, EUR 5,000.
See the Vendor Management Reset →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call