All articles · SRM
Are you a customer of choice? Why suppliers give their best people to other clients
By Celia SGAR · 6 min read
Your supplier decides how much effort your account gets, and which people work on it, from the way you behave as a client. Spend counts for less than most buyers think. I spent six years on the supplier side as an account manager, and our best people went to the clients who were easiest to work with. If your best supplier has gone quiet, check where you sit on their list.
What does a supplier decide that you never see?
Over six years and three roles on the supplier side, I looked after global clients in consumer goods and pharma. Inside the supplier, we made decisions about every account that our clients never heard about. Who got the senior resource when capacity was tight. Who got the proactive call when something went wrong. Who got the minimum, because nobody on the client side expected more.
No contract covers these decisions. The account manager and the delivery team make them week by week, based on what each client makes easy or hard. You segment your suppliers by spend, risk and fit. They segment you too. Most companies I work with never ask where they sit in their suppliers' portfolio.
Why does a supplier give its best people to another client?
Some of the clients who got our best people were small accounts. They paid on time. They came to meetings prepared to contribute. Their briefs were clear, and when scope changed, they talked it through with us before sending a demand. They brought feedback to us first, without going over our heads to our director, and they treated our team as people.
One client sent a three-sentence email after a difficult delivery to thank the team. Someone forwarded it around our office. When the next project came in and capacity was tight, that account got our best resource. Nobody made a formal decision about it. The team wanted to show up for a client who had noticed them.
What does your supplier see when you are the difficult client?
A key account manager reads your governance within a few meetings. They notice whether your review dates sit in the calendar months ahead, whether anyone sends minutes and whether the same people turn up each quarter. When you write nothing down, polite phrases such as "our senior consultant got pulled to another project" close the topic, and nobody on your side follows up.
They count how many voices you speak with. The first time I asked our top 10 suppliers how likely they were to recommend us as a client, the average came back at 6.2 out of 10. Three suppliers scored us 4 or below. One wrote that working with us was like playing telephone. When I looked, 14 different people in our company were giving that supplier direction, with conflicting requests from IT, Operations and Finance. We were the difficult client.
They see how you pay. One strategic partner escalated to my boss after waiting 87 days for an invoice that Finance had already approved. It sat in the same queue as a $500 office order, and they told us they were rethinking the partnership.
And they see who you thank. I once asked a departing supplier why they were not bidding on the renewal. They had scored 4.5 for three years and never once received a thank-you, while our underperformers got weekly meetings, executive involvement and detailed feedback. We were teaching suppliers that the way to get our attention was to underperform.
What does it cost you to slip down the list?
A client came to me frustrated about an IT vendor that had been great for two years. Then tickets took longer, the senior engineer stopped coming to calls and the good ideas dried up. The contract, the prices and the SLAs had not changed. Her team had been skipping the monthly catch-ups, pushing back on every small cost increase, changing scope without warning and answering emails days later. None of it triggered a penalty clause. The vendor noticed anyway and moved its senior resource to a better client.
I call this the Relationship Tax. It never appears on an invoice. You pay it in the service you get, the priority you receive and the effort your vendor puts in when things get hard.
Sometimes the bill is visible. A friend who manages vendors at a pharma company got an email from her cloud provider. They had built a feature that would have solved her data migration problem, but they were not sure she still needed it, so they built it for another client. Her company spent six months and €300K on a workaround for a problem the supplier had already solved for someone else.
How do you know you are not their customer of choice?
You know you have this when:
- •The senior people who won the deal no longer come to your meetings, and more junior names replace them.
- •The key account manager sends the operations team to your quarterly review.
- •Every answer from the account manager is "I'll check" or "I'll get back to you". One told me "you're not my only client" while we were paying millions a year.
- •You hear about a useful new feature after the supplier has built it for someone else.
- •Your supplier hears from you when something breaks, and at no other time.
On client calls I count how often the account manager says "I", "we" or "you". Most clients I work with start at around 80% "I". The account manager is running their own day, and you are a task on it.
What does being a customer of choice look like?
You cannot declare a strategic relationship on your own. You earn your place in their portfolio the same way they earn theirs in yours.
After that survey, we gave each Tier 1 supplier a single point of contact and aligned our internal teams. When I asked the same question six months later, the average had risen to 8.4. The supplier that had given us a 4 gave us a 9 and became one of our most proactive partners. We also gave our Tier 1 suppliers a fast payment lane, and the partner with the 87-day invoice went from almost leaving to bringing us their best people and best ideas.
When I work with my clients, a customer of choice looks like this. Your supplier knows who to call, and that person can commit. Your top suppliers know your priorities before they build their roadmap. High performers hear it when they do well. The senior people stay on your account when capacity is tight. On calls, the account manager talks about your world: after we fix the dynamic, "you" climbs to around 60% of what they say.
Where do you sit on your suppliers' list?
Your suppliers have already ranked you as a client. The free Customer of Choice Self-Score takes about two minutes and shows where you are losing ground. If the result confirms what you suspected, this is the work I do with clients.
Take the Customer of Choice Self-Score →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call