All articles · Supplier performance
When a supplier keeps missing and all you have is complaints
By Celia SGAR · 4 min read
A supplier who keeps missing needs a Supplier Performance Improvement Plan (SPIP). Your team's complaints won't move them. An SPIP gives both sides one written record of the measured gap, who owns the recovery and when you will judge it. The supplier recovers, or you escalate or exit with evidence you can defend.
You know you have this when...
- •Your team complains about the supplier every week, and nobody can put a number on it.
- •The vendor's report shows green while your people describe a different service (the watermelon effect).
- •The same issue comes up at every review and leaves with the same promise.
- •Escalations sit untouched for months because nobody is sure who should raise them.
- •Renewal is close and your honest answer on performance is "fine, I think".
Why do complaints change nothing?
A complaint gives the supplier nothing to measure against. Your team says the service is slow, the account manager says the numbers look fine, and the meeting moves on. Nobody on either side leaves with a gap they both recognise.
I have sat in a renewal where the only answer to "how have they performed?" was "they're fine", and the data we pulled afterwards showed a supplier well below what it claimed (the $4M renewal).
Data alone won't save you if your own side is split. I have walked into a review with every miss documented and still come out with nothing resolved, because my own colleagues arrived with three different agendas (a divided team).
What is a Supplier Performance Improvement Plan for?
An SPIP is the formal recovery agreement for a supplier who scores below 3 on your scorecard. In the SGAR Framework, 3 means meets expectations, the minimum acceptable. A score below 3 means the supplier is missing commitments, and that is where the improvement or exit conversation starts.
I learned why the plan has to be written down at PepsiCo. After a QBR, we identified three areas that needed improvement and the supplier acknowledged every gap. I checked back six weeks later. Area one had no progress. Area two was "we're working on it". On area three, nobody could remember what we had committed to. We had scored them and discussed it, and we had nothing to show. After that, I made documented improvement plans mandatory, and supplier performance improved 23% year over year.
Does an improvement plan damage the supplier relationship?
In my experience, suppliers respond well when you are open with them. I once completed the first assessment of a strategic IT supplier and the overall score came out at 2.8. I sent the scorecard five days before the QBR, worried they would come in angry. Their CEO called me, concerned. They had no idea we felt that way and wanted to meet before the review. They arrived with a 90-day improvement plan already drafted. Two quarters later they scored 3.9.
At Nestlé, a vendor missed three KPIs in a row. I opened the QBR by asking what was getting in the way. Within 40 minutes we found the root cause, within two weeks all three KPIs were back on track, and within a quarter they were a top performer. That supplier never needed a formal plan, and the aim of an SPIP is the same: find out why a supplier is missing and help them recover.
What good looks like
Every supplier below 3 has one written plan that both sides have seen. One person on your side speaks for the whole business, so the supplier hears one message. The supplier knows where they stand before the review starts. At the end of the plan, you know whether they recovered, and any escalation or exit rests on data your CFO would accept.
When I work with my clients, the supplier who keeps missing is often the reason they call. I have run more than 800 supplier reviews in 17+ years of vendor management at PepsiCo, Nestlé, Danone and Zurich Insurance, from the client side and the supplier side. The suppliers who recovered had a clear plan and someone on our side who followed it up.
If a supplier keeps missing and all you have is complaints
Book a diagnostic call. I will ask about your vendor base and how you review your suppliers, and tell you whether a day would fix it.
Book a diagnostic call →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call