All articles · Supplier performance
Your SLA reports are green and the business is still unhappy
By Celia SGAR · 5 min read
When your supplier's SLA report shows green and your teams keep complaining, the report measures too little or the supplier chooses what you see. Vendor managers call this the watermelon effect: green on the outside, red inside. The SLAs hold, and underneath sit poor user experience, slipped projects and problems nobody has put a number on.
What is the watermelon effect in vendor management?
SLAs are the bare minimum a supplier promises in the contract: delivery in 48 hours, 99% uptime. They tell you whether the supplier complied. They tell you little about whether the supplier helps your business. A supplier can hit every SLA while your users wait, work around the tool or stop using it.
I once cancelled a holiday booking in Lapland because of photo 23. The listing showed a room with a glass ceiling over a winter forest. Photos 1 to 22 were stunning. Photo 23 showed the identical room from the identical angle, with the Northern Lights added to the sky. I closed the tab. The edited sky made me doubt every other photo in the listing.
I see the same in vendor QBRs. The dashboards stay green, the slides stay polished and the messages stay optimistic. When you dig into the data underneath, you find the same delays, the same escalations and the same unresolved issues as last quarter.
How do you know you have a watermelon supplier?
You know you have this when you recognise several of these:
- •The supplier brings the slides, picks the metrics and runs the review.
- •The report is all green and your team tells you something different every week.
- •Complaints reach you in corridors and chats and never appear in the review.
- •You leave the review feeling something is off, and you can't prove it.
- •The meeting looks fine, the numbers look fine, and nothing changes afterwards.
- •The first time you show the supplier a red score, they spend the meeting questioning the SLA definition.
Picture a review meeting after the relationship has landed on your desk. The vendor arrives with a deck full of green metrics. Three people in your team complained about response times last month. A project slipped and nobody followed up. You don't have the data to push back, and the vendor does. So you nod, schedule the next meeting and leave with the feeling that something is wrong.
Why do SLA reports stay green while the business suffers?
Your vendor will bring the metrics they know they can win. I've seen this pattern across 17+ years and more than 800 supplier reviews, with the same shape and different company names. It happens in two ways. IT leaders inherit vendor contracts from procurement with no scorecard, no structure and no handover. Procurement leaders are stretched across too many suppliers to run every review, so the vendor fills the gap. The reasons differ and the result is the same: you are nodding at green numbers that don't match what your team tells you.
The SLAs themselves are often part of the problem. Many were written at signature and never discussed with the people who use the service. The vendor does what they think you need, your team hopes for what it needs, and six months later both sides are frustrated. The vendor misses SLAs nobody talked about and hits the ones that no longer matter.
The numbers also leave out the people. When I compared notes with another vendor manager, we both found the watermelon effect showing up most when the vendor hosted the governance meetings. The metrics didn't reflect service quality or user satisfaction, and nobody in the room was asking the business users what they experienced.
What does a green report cost you?
I've walked through a real case of a software vendor with a €1.8M contract. SLAs were green on every report, and the relationship was falling apart from the inside. Nobody could act on it, because on paper nothing was wrong.
More measures do not close the gap on their own. Clients with solid KPI frameworks that have run for years tell me the same thing: the numbers look fine and the relationship feels stuck.
What does good look like?
The report and your teams tell the same story. You walk into the review with your own scorecard, built around what your business needs, and the supplier has seen it before the meeting. The voice of your users sits next to the SLAs, so a complaint in the corridor shows up in the review. When a score is red, everyone in the room already agrees on what it means.
For years I ran QBRs with global IT suppliers, and my first answer to tense reviews was more detailed metrics and clearer dashboards. It didn't work. The tone changed when suppliers saw we also assessed how they worked with us: how well they communicated and how proactive they were. The comment in the room moved from "that score isn't fair" to "how do we improve this together?"
When I work with my clients, we build reviews where the client's voice leads and the supplier responds to a score they already understand. The supplier stops choosing what you see, and your teams stop having to complain in corridors to be heard.
Green report, frustrated team?
If this sounds like one of your suppliers, book a diagnostic call. I will ask about your vendor base and how you review your suppliers, and tell you whether a day would fix it.
Book a diagnostic call →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call