All articles · QBRs
QBR or QVR: does renaming the meeting fix anything?
By Celia SGAR · 5 min read
Renaming a Quarterly Business Review as a Quarterly Value Review changes nothing on its own. The outcome depends on who owns the agenda. When the supplier owns it, you get a sales pitch under a new name. When you, the client, own it, the meeting starts with your priorities and ends with actions someone answers for.
Fred Copestake, a sales coach and author of Selling Through Partnering Skills, wrote a blog post arguing that QBRs are a waste of time. He lists what goes wrong: backward-looking metrics, schedule slips, no structure, the wrong people in the room, poor preparation and poor follow-up. His fix is to rename the meeting the Quarterly Value Review, or QVR. I agree with most of his diagnosis and with part of his cure.
This article is for the IT and procurement leaders who run these meetings every quarter and leave wondering what they achieved. Call it a QBR, a QVR, an EBR or a strategic account review: you face the same question. Who owns the agenda, and who owns the outcome?
Where did the QVR come from?
Brian Sullivan and Dave Mattson formalised the Quarterly Value Review inside the Sandler Enterprise Selling programme and published it in their book Sandler Enterprise Selling: Winning, Growing, and Retaining Major Accounts. They designed it as a sales tool: a two-page form that keeps account executives engaged with major clients after the contract is signed, so they stay visible between signature and renewal.
Sellers built the QVR to fix a problem sellers created: the botched handoff. Sales wins the deal on a big promise and then steps away. Delivery arrives and focuses on technical milestones. The client's executive sponsor never sees the strategic outcomes they bought, and by renewal they are frustrated and the relationship is fragile.
Fred's article comes from the same lineage. His advice speaks to the supplier side: how to run a better meeting so your client doesn't feel you are wasting their time. He is right that most supplier-run QBRs are boring, tactical and self-congratulatory. We part ways on who should run the meeting.
Who should own the QBR agenda?
The client. In 17+ years managing IT vendors at PepsiCo, Nestlé, Danone and Zurich Insurance, I've sat through more than 800 of these meetings. In the best ones, the client led the agenda.
When the supplier owns the agenda, the meeting drifts towards what the supplier wants to discuss: new features, upsell opportunities, their version of the performance story, and slides of tickets resolved and SLAs met. Even when they call it a Value Review, the value on the table is the value the supplier wants credit for.
When you own the agenda, the meeting opens with your priorities: what is changing in your business, what you need from the relationship in the next 90 days, what is broken and what you want to escalate. The supplier comes prepared to respond to that.
Control of the agenda is what separates a strategic vendor relationship from an expensive coffee chat. A new name leaves that control where it was. If the supplier still sets the agenda, you still get a sales pitch.
What goes wrong in most QBRs?
Fred's list matches what I see in client engagements:
- •They look backwards. They open with last quarter's metrics, the supplier presents green slides, the client nods and nothing changes.
- •They slip. The quarterly rhythm drifts to twice a year, then once a year, then only when something breaks.
- •They have no structure. The same meeting runs three different ways depending on who shows up, with no continuity from one quarter to the next.
- •The wrong people attend. Operational teams meet operational teams, senior sponsors stay away, nobody can make decisions and the issues stay parked.
- •Preparation is poor and follow-up is worse. Someone logs the actions and everyone forgets them by week two, so the next QBR rediscovers the same problems.
Fred is right about all of this, and so is the Sandler research. What neither covers is who is responsible for fixing it.
Why is the QBR a client responsibility?
I built the SGAR Framework around four pillars: Strategy, Governance, Assessment and Relationship. The QBR sits inside Governance, and in SGAR the client owns Governance outright.
You decide:
- •How often the meeting happens
- •Who attends from both sides
- •What the agenda covers
- •Which metrics you review
- •Which actions you track between meetings
- •Who escalates what, to whom
The supplier supports. They prepare the data you ask for, bring the right people, commit to actions and report on progress. They contribute their view on innovation and risk. You drive.
Some procurement and IT teams find this uncomfortable, because owning the QBR means doing the work. You build the agenda and send it five days before the meeting. You chair the discussion, follow up on actions and check that what the supplier reported matches reality.
Letting the supplier handle it is easier. They have the slides ready, they have a template and they want to run it. So you let them, and then you wonder why nothing changes after the meeting.
What does a client-led QBR look like?
In a client-led QBR, you set the frame. The meeting starts from your priorities and what is changing in your business. The performance discussion rests on a scorecard both sides agreed, so the supplier answers with evidence. The hour ends with actions someone owns, with dates, and the next QBR opens by checking them. The supplier brings their content too, and it sits inside your frame.
When I work with vendor managers stuck in supplier-led QBRs, we change the agenda flow first. Within one or two cycles the meeting changes. Senior people start attending because the meeting is about something. Teams resolve issues they had parked for a year, and performance scores move because everyone is looking at the same data.
Is “value” a buzzword?
Mostly, yes. “Value” is one of the most overused words in B2B. Sandler's QVR has structure behind it (thirteen satisfaction factors, seven discussion areas and a service scorecard), and that structure is useful. Force Management's value framework adds rigour.
A rebrand on its own changes nothing. A supplier who runs a bad QBR will run a bad QVR, with “value” in the slide header and the same content underneath.
If the new name gets vendor managers, IT leaders and procurement teams to treat these meetings as strategic, send senior people, prepare properly and follow up, then the word has earned its keep. I'm in favour of whatever stops these meetings being expensive coffee chats.
What I won't accept is the supplier leading the meeting, whatever you call it. The QBR, the QVR, the EBR and the strategic review all belong to the client. The supplier who controls the agenda controls the outcome, so if you want different outcomes from your vendor relationships, take the agenda back.
Related: Why your QBRs with IT vendors run long and end without decisions
How client-led are your QBRs?
Take the QBR quiz to check your current reviews and see what to fix first.
Take the QBR quiz →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call