All articles · QBRs
Why your QBRs with IT vendors run long and end without decisions
By Celia SGAR · 4 min read
Your QBRs with IT vendors run long and end without decisions because the supplier fills the time and nobody on your side owns the outcome. After 800+ supplier reviews at PepsiCo, Nestlé and Danone, I can tell in five minutes whether a review will produce decisions or turn into an expensive coffee chat.
What does a QBR that goes nowhere look like?
I had been at one company for exactly one week when I sat in my first Quarterly Business Review with our largest IT supplier, a third of our entire IT spend. The CIO was there, several executives, the head of vendor management.
The supplier spent 20 minutes on FTE allocations by geography, 30 minutes on a cloud migration offering we were not buying, 40 minutes on their resource org charts and 25 minutes on their own sales targets. Then 15 minutes of "next steps" that nobody wrote down, and 20 minutes of polite thank-yous.
Two and a half hours. Nobody mentioned their performance against the SLAs, the 47 open support tickets, or why our last three projects came in late and over budget. Nobody questioned it, because this was normal.
How do you know your QBRs have the same problem?
- •Your supplier presents and your team listens.
- •There are so many KPIs that nobody knows what to focus on.
- •Every quarter starts from zero, with no link to the last review.
- •Actions live in someone's inbox, or nowhere.
- •Every vendor gets the same meeting, whatever their spend or risk.
- •You walk out with promises and no dates, names or scope.
That last one catches good teams too. In one 90-minute QBR with an IT supplier I counted "we can help" 17 times. Migration running late? We can help. Reporting still broken? We can help. I walked out with nothing I could plan around. "We can help" sounds like a yes and commits to nothing.
What do these meetings cost you?
The time is the smallest cost. A QBR with the CIO and several executives in the room for two and a half hours is expensive, and it produces nothing you can act on.
The bigger cost is what does not happen. The open tickets stay open. The late projects stay late, and the supplier learns that your review is a stage for their roadmap. Your executives learn something too: that vendor management is admin, and the meeting can be skipped next quarter.
Why do QBRs keep running this way?
Three years into my role at Nestlé, I sat in yet another QBR that was going nowhere. The vendor had prepared 47 slides. Our team was not aligned. The executive sponsor checked his phone. Two hours later we walked out with vague promises and no documented commitments.
The supplier was not the problem. They came prepared, as suppliers do. We came as an audience. When your own side has not agreed what it wants from the meeting, the supplier fills the space, and a divided team hands them the agenda.
Renaming the meeting does not change this either. I wrote about that in QBR or QVR: does renaming the meeting fix anything?
What does a QBR that works give you?
A good QBR is shorter than you expect and ends with decisions. You walk in knowing how the supplier performed, because the numbers were shared before the meeting. Your team speaks with one voice. The hour goes on the few issues that matter and on what happens next, and every action leaves the room with an owner and a date.
Is your QBR a coffee chat?
Ten yes/no questions on how you run your supplier reviews, and what to fix first. If you want the QBRs rebuilt with your team, book a diagnostic call.
Take the QBR quiz →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call