All articles · SRM

Why so many SRM programmes fail

By Celia SGAR · 8 min read

In my experience, most SRM programmes fail, and the cause sits with the buyer.

SRM is an investment, and it gives back more than it costs. It lowers risk. It brings supplier ideas into your business. It gets value out of contracts you already signed and already paid for. Nobody argues with that part. The business case has worked for many years.

However, the programmes still fall over, often in the first few months.

I have worked in the IT Vendor Management space for 17+ years. Client side, and supplier side too. I have sat in more than 800 supplier reviews across 8 countries. After a while I saw the same seven failures, in the same order, and each one makes the next one worse.

1. Executives do not own the programme

Usually one person runs it, and they run it on top of a full job. They believe in it. They built the templates, they chase the meetings, they keep the log. And their name sits nowhere on a slide that leadership reads.

Without a name on that slide, the programme has no budget of its own, no authority to bring other teams in and no cover when things get tight.

The programme runs on goodwill, and goodwill gets cut first. Somebody moves that person to a sourcing project for a quarter, and nothing burns down, because nothing visible breaks when SRM stops. The templates sit in a folder. The meetings drop off the calendar one by one.

Then a supplier fails badly eighteen months later, and everybody asks why nobody saw it coming.

The other six problems all start here.

2. Governance becomes a theatre

The first quarter looks good: real QBRs, a live action log, updates going up the chain. Somebody sends the agenda a week ahead and people read it.

The second quarter starts the slide. The agenda goes out two days before. One action closes late and nobody chases it. Your sponsor misses a meeting and sends a deputy.

By the third quarter nobody prepares anything. Somebody reads slides for 40 minutes. The same actions roll over again. Half the invited people send apologies, and the ones who come in have not opened the pack.

Then the supplier starts writing the agenda, because your side stopped. Their deck, their numbers, their version of how the quarter went. You spend the hour reacting to their story.

The meeting stays in the diary, and nobody gets anything out of it.

3. The scorecard measures everything and tells you nothing

Some scorecards carry 30 or 40 metrics. Teams build them that way to look serious, and you read the page and learn nothing.

There is a second problem. Your supplier will manage the metric. Give them a target and they protect the target. Economists call this Goodhart's Law. The SLAs go green while the relationship gets worse.

Four areas tell you almost everything: operations, partnership, innovation, commercial. That is the standard scorecard. The rest fills space.

The measures under each area change with what you buy and with how strategic the supplier is. Same four areas for everybody, and a short page you can read in a minute.

I ran a scorecard on those four areas with 12 strategic vendors for three years. In the first year, performance went up 13% across the base. The numbers forced better conversations, and the conversations fixed issues.

4. Everyone owns a piece, nobody owns the relationship

Procurement owns the contract. The business owns delivery. Finance owns the budget. The centre of excellence owns the framework and has no authority.

Each one does their job. Procurement tracks the terms. The business tracks the tickets. Finance tracks the spend. Everybody reports green on their own piece.

So a decision comes up and nobody takes it, because nobody owns the whole thing. Renewal in four months and nobody has a view. The supplier asks for a scope change and three teams send three different answers. Somebody needs to tell them their service dropped, and everybody assumes another team already did.

The relationship then sits with no owner until something goes wrong. Then a name appears, usually somebody senior, usually in a crisis meeting.

5. The tooling cannot see a relationship

Most SRM still runs on an ERP module and a few spreadsheets. Those tools handle transactions well, which is what somebody built them for.

They cannot hold three years of history. They cannot hold what your supplier promised in a room back in March. They cannot show you a relationship going cold.

And the spreadsheet has an owner. One person keeps the master file, adds a tab every quarter, and remembers which column means what. That person changes role and the file stops making sense to everybody else. I have opened plenty of those files. Fifteen tabs, three colour codes, and no way to tell what happened in year one.

So you walk into a renewal with last quarter's numbers and nothing before that. You cannot show a trend. You cannot prove the service dropped after the account manager changed. You argue from memory, and your supplier argues from their data.

Your tools see this month's invoice, so your team reacts to this month's problem.

6. Suppliers give their best to whoever runs the best programme

Your supplier reads your programme in about one meeting.

I know this from the other chair. I worked for a supplier before, an HR services provider. You look at the client's governance, their scorecard, how prepared they walk in. Then you decide how much of your good thinking to bring and which people to put on the account.

Run SRM as a compliance exercise and your supplier does the same back. You get a junior account manager, last quarter's deck, and none of their sharper ideas.

Those ideas go to the client who asks better questions and does something with the answers.

You run a light programme on your supplier. Your supplier runs a full Key Account Management programme on you. They have a named account director, a budget, a plan to grow your spend, and a list of your people to keep close. You have a quarterly meeting nobody prepared for.

7. The value comes after signature, and nobody watches it

Sourcing gets all the attention. Months of work go in. Business case, RFP, evaluation, negotiation. People negotiate hard, celebrate the signature and leave.

Procurement moves to the next deal. The executives from the kick-off stop coming. The relationship goes quiet, and everybody treats quiet as good news.

Then the contract meets real life. Volumes change. Your business reorganises. The account manager who understood your setup moves on. Somebody agrees a small workaround in a Tuesday call and writes it down nowhere. None of this looks like a problem at the time.

The value you signed for is in the delivery after signature. In the daily work. In the way those terms hold up against real operations. Nobody governs that part, so the savings in the business case never reach the accounts.

And nobody goes back to check. The business case gets approved, filed, and stays closed. Ask a team two years in whether they got the savings they promised. Most cannot tell you.

The root cause

Go back through the seven. Your own organisation decided every one of them, mostly without noticing.

Somebody left a name off a slide. Somebody copied a scorecard template with 40 lines on it. Somebody moved the one person who cared onto a sourcing project. Small calls, made by busy people, each one reasonable on the day.

Treat SRM as admin work and you get admin work with a scorecard attached.

Give it a senior owner, governance that survives past the third quarter, and tools that see the relationship. Then it pays you back.

A supplier relationship gets worse on its own, even when nobody does anything wrong. Your supplier reallocates their good people. Your business changes and the contract does not. SRM stops the drop when somebody runs it well.

Before your next review

Answer these three questions.

If you answered the wrong way, the programme has already failed, even if nobody has booked the post-mortem.

Somebody decided each of these seven things, and somebody can decide them again. When I work with my clients, we decide them together: who owns each strategic relationship, what the scorecard measures, and which reviews end in decisions. That work starts with the Vendor Management Reset.

So where does your programme sit today?

What is no SRM costing you?

Put your own spend and supplier numbers into the SRM ROI calculator and see the value you leave on the table after signature.

Open the SRM ROI calculator →

Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call