All articles · Vendor management
The Vendor Day One Checklist: 6 conversations to have before work starts
By Celia SGAR · 3 min read
Most vendor relationships fail in the silence after the contract is signed.
The vendor assumes you'll tell them what you need. You assume they'll deliver what they promised. Your team assumes procurement is managing the relationship. Procurement assumes operations has it covered.
Six months later, SLAs are missed, invoices don't match scope, and both sides are pointing fingers.
After 17+ years managing vendors at PepsiCo, Nestlé, Danone, and Zurich Insurance, I've seen this play out hundreds of times. Almost every time, the root cause is the same: nobody had the right conversation on day one.
These are the six conversations I wish someone had told me about at the start of my career.
Why most vendor kickoff meetings fail
Most IT leaders and procurement teams spend months getting a contract over the line. Vendor selection, negotiation, legal review, stakeholder sign-off. It's exhausting.
Then the contract lands and everyone relaxes.
The vendor gets a welcome email. Maybe a call. Then the work starts, with both sides carrying different assumptions about how the relationship will work.
I call this the Day One Gap: the space between contract signature and a structured relationship. Most vendor problems start here.
The fix is a 60-minute conversation before the work starts.
The 6 conversations every vendor kickoff needs
1. Set expectations in plain English
Your contract has SLA language, and your vendor has read it. Reading an SLA and knowing what good looks like in practice are two different things. Most vendors never hear from the client what a good week looks like. The ones that do perform better.
2. Ask what they need from you
Most clients never ask. They assume the vendor will flag problems when they arise. Vendors, especially new ones, are often reluctant to say "your team is slow to approve things" or "we never know who to contact when there's an issue." Those problems stay hidden until they cost you.
3. Agree your governance cadence
Who talks to whom, how often, and about what. If you wait until something goes wrong to have this conversation, it's too late, and the first real meeting becomes an escalation.
4. Introduce your scorecard before you use it
Nothing damages a vendor relationship faster than a surprise performance review. When the vendor knows from the start how you will judge them, both sides work toward the same outcome.
5. Agree the escalation process
Problems will happen. When nobody agreed in advance what happens next, a small issue turns into weeks of finger-pointing. This conversation is short. Skipping it can cost months.
6. Define what success looks like in 90 days
Both sides need the same picture of a good first quarter. Without it, your first quarterly review has nothing to measure against, and each side arrives with its own story.
What happens when you skip this conversation
I inherited a vendor relationship at one of my Fortune 500 clients that was three months from termination.
The vendor wasn't underperforming on purpose. Nobody had told them what good looked like, agreed what to do when things went wrong, or owned the relationship after signature.
We sat down, had all six conversations, wrote everything down, and reviewed it every quarter.
Twelve months later they were the highest-performing vendor in that category.
The contract and the vendor stayed the same. What changed was that we had the conversations.
After day one
I've turned these six conversations into a free one-page Day One Vendor Checklist you can keep for your next vendor kickoff.
Day one sets the tone. What keeps a supplier relationship on track after that is an owner, a review rhythm and a scorecard both sides trust. Setting those up for your strategic suppliers is the work I do with my clients, starting with the Vendor Management Reset.
Starting with a new strategic vendor?
Book a diagnostic call and we will look at how your supplier relationships run after signature, and what to put in place first.
Book a diagnostic call →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call