All articles · Supplier performance
Supplier scorecards: what Gartner found, and why most of them fail
By Celia SGAR · 3 min read
Gartner's research on supplier scorecards points to what I've seen in more than 800 supplier reviews: a scorecard pays off when you segment your suppliers first, measure more than delivery, and act on the score. These are Gartner's findings, and what they mean for the way you run your suppliers.
What does Gartner's research say about supplier scorecards?
- •Most companies that practise SRM already score their suppliers: 62% use supplier scorecards to measure performance.
- •Few scorecards measure enough. Only 22% of procurement organisations use scorecards that combine operational and non-operational metrics.
- •Few companies know which suppliers matter most. Only 35% of chief procurement officers have a working model for telling their most critical suppliers apart by value.
- •Scoring brings ideas. Gartner reports that its supplier scorecards generate more than twice as many applied supplier ideas.
Gartner's research note Supplier Performance Management: It's More Than a Scorecard; It's a Strategy makes the same point in its title. The scorecard is one tool inside a wider way of running your suppliers.
Why do supplier scorecards fail?
Gartner lists four ways scorecards fail to show a supplier's value:
- •Measuring as many suppliers as possible
- •Using one scorecard for every supplier
- •Keeping the results away from the supply base
- •Never asking the supplier what the buyer needs to change
I would add a fifth from my own reviews: too many metrics. Some scorecards carry 30 or 40 lines. You read the page and learn nothing, and the supplier learns to manage the metric. The SLAs go green while the relationship gets worse.
What does a scorecard that works look like?
The SGAR Framework has four pillars: Strategy, Governance, Assessment and Relationship. Each one answers one of Gartner's findings.
- •Strategy decides which suppliers matter most, so only those get a full scorecard and a named owner.
- •Governance puts the score in front of the supplier before the review, so the meeting ends in decisions with owners and dates.
- •Assessment measures more than delivery on one short scorecard you can compare across suppliers.
- •Relationship asks the supplier what you need to change, the question on Gartner's list most buyers skip.
Gartner puts it plainly: scoring must come with action. Top scorers earn visibility and more business. Suppliers who stay low face clear consequences.
I spent years on the supplier side, managing IT client accounts. From that chair you read the client's governance in one meeting, and you decide how much of your good thinking to bring. When I work with my clients, I ask the supplier the question on Gartner's list: what do we need to change so you can perform better?
What did this deliver at Danone?
I ran a scorecard on four areas with Danone's 12 strategic IT vendors for three years. In the first year, aggregate performance rose 13% across the base. The numbers fixed nothing on their own. They forced better conversations, and the conversations fixed the issues.
What would this look like for your suppliers?
When I work with my clients, we finish with every strategic supplier on one short scorecard, a named owner for each relationship, and reviews that end in decisions. Which suppliers get a scorecard, what goes on it and how much each area counts depend on your supplier base. That is the work I do with you in the Vendor Management Reset.
Is your scorecard telling you anything?
Book a diagnostic call and we will look at your scorecards and your supplier reviews together.
Book a diagnostic call →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call