All articles · SGAR Framework
The Assessment pillar: when you cannot tell how your suppliers perform
By Celia SGAR · 3 min read
Supplier assessment tells you how each supplier performs, in a form you can discuss with them and act on. When it works, your supplier conversations start from evidence. When it is missing, you rely on gut feeling or a last-minute annual survey and hope your vendors are doing what you expect.
Assessment is the A in the SGAR Framework (Strategy, Governance, Assessment, Relationship).
How do you know your supplier assessment is not working?
I see two common failures. Some organisations measure everything, so nobody uses the results. Others measure nothing, so issues arrive as surprises. You will recognise some of these signs:
- •Each team scores its suppliers in a different way, so you cannot compare them.
- •The supplier sees its score for the first time in the review, and the hour goes on arguing about the numbers.
- •Scores stay green quarter after quarter while the relationship gets worse.
- •Renewal comes round and you argue from memory, because nobody kept the trend.
What does good supplier assessment look like?
Good assessment is a repeatable process with three parts:
- •Scorecards that fit the supplier type.
- •Reviews on a regular rhythm through the year.
- •Feedback the supplier can act on, backed by data.
I use the same four areas for every supplier: Operations, Partnership, Innovation and Procurement. Because every supplier sits under the same four areas, you can compare suppliers against each other even when they provide different products and services. The measures under each area change with what you buy, which is why one template copied across your supplier base rarely works.
How can procurement use assessment data?
Use the data to recognise your best suppliers as well as to address underperformance. Suppliers who score high review after review are good candidates for more business. The scores also give procurement a factual basis for negotiations on pricing, service and bonuses for high performers.
What changes when assessment works?
Every strategic supplier has a short scorecard it has seen before the review. You can see the trend over time, strong partners get recognised, and the rest get a clear case for improvement. You move out of firefighting and finger-pointing, and that gives you a solid base for the Relationship pillar.
At Danone I ran a scorecard on these four areas with 12 strategic IT vendors for three years. In the first year, aggregate performance rose 13% across the base.
Designing the scorecards, choosing the measures for each type of supplier and deciding how often each one gets reviewed is the work I do with my clients. We build your first weighted scorecard together in the Vendor Management Reset.
The SGAR series: Strategy · Governance · Assessment · the whole framework
Do your scorecards lead to decisions?
Book a diagnostic call and we will look at how you assess your suppliers today and where the gaps are.
Book a diagnostic call →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call