All articles · Vendor management
5 warning signs your Vendor Management strategy needs to change
By Celia SGAR · 7 min read
Vendor Management rarely breaks overnight.
A QBR gets rescheduled for the third time. A vendor misses an SLA and nobody notices for two months. Your team spends Monday morning untangling a supplier issue that someone should have flagged weeks ago.
Each problem feels small on its own. Together, they cost real money.
World Commerce & Contracting found that companies lose an average of 9% of contract value after signature, through what happens (or doesn't happen) once the contract is signed.
I have spent 17+ years managing global vendor relationships for PepsiCo, Nestlé, Danone, and Zurich Insurance. The same warning signs show up in every organization where Vendor Management is stuck in reactive mode. In my experience, by the time leadership notices, the damage is done.
These are the five signs I look for. If you recognize three or more, your Vendor Management needs more than a tune-up.
Warning sign 1: your team spends more time firefighting than planning
You know the pattern. Monday starts with an urgent email about a vendor issue. By Wednesday, your team is buried in escalations. Friday arrives and nobody has touched the strategic work that was supposed to get done this week.
Reactive Vendor Management consumes up to 40% more staff time than structured approaches (APQC). That time comes out of the strategic work that would prevent next week's fires.
Firefighting also feels productive. Your team resolves the issue, leadership sees quick action, and everyone moves on. Then the same types of issues come back every quarter because nobody has a system to catch them early.
When I worked with a multinational client on SGAR implementation, their vendor team was spending 60% of their time on reactive issue management. Within one quarter of structured governance, the team resolved issues faster and on facts, and won back days of capacity for strategic work.
What this signal tells you:
You have no governance cadence to catch problems early. Without an early warning system, everything becomes urgent.
Warning sign 2: your QBRs produce meeting notes and no commitments
I call these "coffee chat QBRs." Everyone shows up, the vendor presents slides about how great they are, your team nods politely, someone takes notes, and everyone leaves.
Nobody documents action items with owners and deadlines, reviews the scorecard against agreed metrics, or follows up on last quarter's promises. The QBR sits on the calendar and produces no outcomes.
Research from Deloitte shows 72% of companies say SRM is a priority. Only 20% have a structured governance model to support it.
Without a clear agenda, a scoring framework, and consequences tied to results, a QBR is a meeting with catering. Vendors learn fast which clients hold them accountable, and those clients get better service.
What this signal tells you:
You have meetings with no governance framework behind them. The Assessment pillar of your Vendor Management is missing, and your vendors know it.
Warning sign 3: every category manager does scorecards differently (or not at all)
Open five vendor scorecards from five different teams in your organization. If they look like five different documents, you have a standardization problem.
One team tracks 15 KPIs. Another tracks 3. A third hasn't updated their scorecard in six months. There is no common scoring rubric, so "good performance" means something different depending on who is filling out the form.
I see this pattern all the time. Organizations know they should measure vendor performance, so they create templates and send them out. Then nobody has time to fill them in, or people enter the same scores every quarter because the results carry no consequences.
When Gartner finds that scorecards generate more than twice as many applied supplier ideas, the scorecards behind that result use consistent, standardised measurement with clear consequences.
What this signal tells you:
Without standardized assessment and clear accountability, your scorecards are decoration.
Warning sign 4: suppliers have stopped bringing you ideas
Think about your top three vendors. When was the last time one of them came to you with an unsolicited idea? A process improvement. A cost reduction opportunity. A new approach they saw working for another client.
If you struggle to answer that question, your vendor relationships have become transactional.
McKinsey found that companies with mature SRM programs see 45% more supplier-led innovation. Vendors bring their best ideas to clients who share strategic context, treat them as partners, and invest in the relationship past contract compliance.
When suppliers stop bringing ideas, it means one of two things. Either they do not understand your business well enough to know what would help, or they have learned that ideas go nowhere because you have no way to evaluate, fund, or implement them.
Both point to how you run the relationship.
At Danone, one of the early wins from SGAR implementation was a shift in supplier behavior. Once vendors had transparent scorecards and structured governance meetings, they started coming to the table with improvement suggestions. Innovation went up once they had a place to bring ideas.
What this signal tells you:
The Relationship pillar is missing. Your vendors do the minimum because the relationship doesn't reward anything more.
Warning sign 5: leadership sees Vendor Management as admin work
This one hurts the most because it affects your career.
If leadership only contacts you when something goes wrong with a vendor, if you are never invited to strategic planning meetings, if people see procurement as "the cost police" rather than a business partner, your organization has relegated Vendor Management to admin work.
The frustrating part is that you know it should be strategic. You see the risks that leadership doesn't. You know which vendors are underperforming. You know there are savings being left on the table.
Without structured data, executive dashboards, and a clear framework connecting vendor performance to business outcomes, you lack the evidence to make the strategic case.
This is the most common frustration I hear from procurement directors and IT vendor managers. They have the knowledge and lack a system that makes it visible to decision-makers.
What this signal tells you:
You have a positioning problem rooted in a visibility problem. Without structured reporting and governance tied to business outcomes, Vendor Management stays invisible to the people who fund it.
The common thread: missing structure
If you recognized three or more of these signs, look at the structure before you look at your team. Your team is working hard, doing what they think is right with the tools and processes they have.
What's missing is a segmentation strategy, a governance rhythm, standardized assessment, and a relationship framework.
These are the four pillars of the SGAR Framework: Strategy, Governance, Assessment, Relationship. Each warning sign above maps to a gap in one or more of these pillars.
These gaps compound over time. Unstructured Vendor Management costs 15-30% more in hidden costs, missed SLA credits, preventable escalations, and unrealized innovation.
What to do about it
Fixing one sign at a time gives you temporary relief. The gaps sit in the structure, so the fix has to cover segmentation, governance, assessment and the relationship together, starting with the suppliers that matter most.
That is the work I do with my clients. In the Vendor Management Reset, a one-day session, we find the gaps costing you the most and set up the foundations together. If you want to build the full system over 12 weeks, the 90-Day Supplier Governance Programme takes it from there, and I attend your first live QBRs with you.
FAQ: Vendor Management warning signs
How do I know if my Vendor Management problems are serious enough to need a new system?
If you recognized three or more of the five warning signs, you are past the point where small fixes work. The signs compound: poor governance leads to reactive firefighting, which leads to burnt-out teams, which leads to leadership seeing Vendor Management as admin. If you fix one symptom and leave the structural gaps, you get temporary relief and then the same problems again.
What is the cost of doing nothing?
Unstructured Vendor Management costs 15-30% more than structured approaches through hidden costs: unclaimed SLA credits, preventable escalations, vendor churn and replacement costs, missed innovation, and wasted team capacity.
Where should I start?
With the warning sign that costs you the most, and with your most important supplier. What to fix first depends on your supplier base and your team, and that is what we work out together on a diagnostic call.
How long does a full Vendor Management rebuild take?
With focused effort and the right support, 90 days is enough to build a working system for your strategic vendors. What 90 days of SGAR gives you covers what your team has at the end.
Does the SGAR Framework work for small vendor portfolios?
Yes. If you manage 10 or more strategic suppliers, SGAR scales to fit. The Strategy pillar helps you segment so you apply full governance only where it drives the most value. Tier 2 and Tier 3 vendors get a lighter touch.
Key takeaways
-
1
Firefighting replaces planning when there is no governance cadence to catch problems early.
-
2
QBRs without structure produce meeting notes with no commitments, and vendors notice.
-
3
Inconsistent scorecards mean nobody trusts the data, so nobody acts on it.
-
4
Silent suppliers signal that the relationship has gone transactional.
-
5
Leadership perception won't change until Vendor Management has structured data tied to business outcomes.
The common thread: missing structure.
The fix: the SGAR Framework (Strategy, Governance, Assessment, Relationship) gives you the system most organizations lack.
Recognised three or more signs?
Book a diagnostic call and we will find the gaps costing you the most and what fixing them looks like for you.
Book a diagnostic call →Vendor Management Reset · Consulting · Book a 20-minute diagnostic call